New York Yankees infielder Jazz Chisholm Jr. got engaged to his girlfriend, singer and social media personality Ahnalys Santiago, during a Christmas Day proposal under the Northern Lights, according to social media posts shared by the couple Friday.
Chisholm, 27, popped the question during a holiday getaway to Finland. A joint Instagram post showed the Bahamian-born star on one knee in a snowy landscape, illuminated by the green glow of the aurora borealis.
View this post on Instagram
“I’m not Da Gurl anymore yallllll I’m DA WIFEEEEEEEE,” Santiago wrote in a celebratory caption accompanying photos of her large oval-cut diamond ring. “I guess when you know you know & he ain’t playing bout me.”
The announcement capped a whirlwind week for the couple, who recently went viral for a provocative Christmas-themed video that drew mixed reactions from baseball fans. In the clip, the pair appeared in matching Grinch pajamas, engaging in suggestive movements that some social media users deemed “in poor taste” for a holiday post, while others defended the couple’s right to share their private lives.
Social media reaction to the engagement was swift and varied. On platforms like X and Reddit, many Yankees fans offered congratulations, with some jokingly urging the team to “extend him now” following his historic 30-homer, 30-steal season in 2025.
However, the news also reignited debates regarding the couple’s public image. While mainstream reports identified Santiago as a singer, her active presence on subscription-based platforms like OnlyFans prompted a wave of commentary from critics. Some users shared disparaging memes or questioned if the “distractions” would affect Chisholm’s performance on the field, while others pushed back against the “thug” labels and “racist” undertones present in some negative threads.
Chisholm, known for his flamboyant “Prince Jazz” persona and high-energy play, appeared unfazed by the online chatter. Following the engagement, he posted a cryptic message on X suggesting his “fiancé is banning me” from the platform, seemingly poking fun at the constant stream of notifications.
The engagement provides a personal high note for Chisholm at the end of a season where the Yankees were eliminated in the ALDS. He remains under contract with New York through 2026.
University and team officials have not issued a statement on the personal milestone, which is customary for offseason engagements. The couple has not yet announced a wedding date.
Flip the pages for some of Ms. Mac’s OnlyFans work.
