In the high-pressure ecosystem of Ohio State football, a single loss can feel like a catastrophe. But as the smoke clears from the latest explosion of controversy at the University of Michigan, Buckeyes fans are receiving a stark reminder of what a true catastrophe actually looks like.
While Ryan Day has faced scrutiny for the occasional stumble in The Game or the College Football Playoff, the stability he has maintained in Columbus stands in sharp contrast to the systemic collapse occurring in Ann Arbor.
For the last three years, the narrative in college football has been dominated by Michigan’s resurgence on the field, but that success has been accompanied by a relentless drumbeat of investigations, suspensions, arrests, and firings. As the Buckeyes prepare for the future, the chaos up north serves as a cautionary tale: sustained excellence requires more than just winning; it requires a foundation of integrity that Ohio State has maintained under Day’s leadership.
The Chaos in Ann Arbor
To understand the value of Ryan Day’s tenure, one must only look at the timeline of turmoil that has engulfed Michigan. The scandals have been numerous, overlapping, and severe:
-
The Connor Stalions Scandal: An elaborate, illegal sign-stealing operation that tainted the program’s national championship run and led to the suspension of Jim Harbaugh.
-
Recruiting Violations: The NCAA investigation into recruiting during the COVID-19 dead period—often trivialized as “Burgergate”—which exposed a lack of institutional control.
-
The Matt Weiss Investigation: The firing of the co-offensive coordinator amid a police investigation into computer access crimes at the university’s hockey facility.
-
The Sherrone Moore Era: The hand-picked successor to Harbaugh lasted less than two seasons before being fired for cause and subsequently arrested on felony charges of home invasion and stalking.
-
Allegations of Misconduct: Recent reports involving sexual misconduct allegations and the solicitation of “illicit favors” have further damaged the program’s reputation.
In a span of fewer than 36 months, Michigan has seen its head coach suspended twice and leave for the NFL, its next head coach fired and arrested, and its reputation tarnished by multiple NCAA inquiries.
The Ryan Day Standard
In contrast, Ryan Day has run a program defined by stability and professionalism. Since taking over for Urban Meyer, Day has kept Ohio State free of major NCAA infractions and off-field legal issues.
While critics often focus on the margins—a missed field goal against Georgia or a close loss to Michigan—Day’s overall resume remains elite. He boasts one of the highest winning percentages in college football history for an active coach. Under his watch, Ohio State has remained a perennial playoff contender without sacrificing the university’s integrity.
Day has proven that a program can operate at a championship level without cutting corners or inviting the kind of institutional chaos that currently plagues its biggest rival.
The Premiere Program in America
Beyond the wins and losses, the metrics suggest that Ohio State has solidified its status as the country’s preeminent college football brand under Day’s stewardship.
-
TV Dominance: The Buckeyes consistently participate in the highest-rated games of the season, driving viewership numbers that dwarf other programs.
-
NFL Production: Ohio State continues to produce NFL talent at a higher rate than nearly any other school, with a constant stream of first-round draft picks reinforcing the program’s elite development.
-
Fan Base Reach: With the largest and most engaged fan base in the nation, the Buckeyes remain the economic engine of the Big Ten.
Trusting the Process
It is natural for a fan base with championship-or-bust expectations to feel frustration after a loss. However, the current landscape of college football proves that the alternative to Ryan Day is not necessarily perfection—it is often instability.
History shows that elite coaches are difficult to find and even harder to replace. As Michigan navigates a complete institutional reset and legal fallout, Ohio State remains a firmly entrenched juggernaut.
The occasional loss is the price of admission in high-level sports. But as events elsewhere have proven, the price of instability is far higher. With the program secure, the talent pipeline flowing, and the coaching staff scandal-free, the evidence suggests Ohio State remains in great hands.
