Jay Williams Calls Out Stephen A. Smith Over His ‘White Brothers’ Lakers Comments

Side-by-side portraits of ESPN analysts Stephen A. Smith, holding a First Take microphone, and Jay Williams.
Stephen A. Smith, left, and Jay Williams. (USA TODAY Network/USA TODAY Sports)

Jay Williams pushed back again Thursday morning at Stephen A. Smith, asking his ESPN colleague to consider how the same kind of racial framing would be received if a white analyst aimed it at Black quarterbacks.

“Stephen A., imagine a white analyst asking on national TV, ‘Y’all really gonna let these Black quarterbacks win another Super Bowl?’ We both know how that would land,” Williams wrote. “I get the culture. I get the barbershop talk. But familiarity doesn’t make something right. We should be able to challenge each other’s thinking without making it personal.”

The post was Williams’ second public reply in an exchange that started after Smith, on Wednesday’s “First Take,” questioned whether Black NBA players would let the Los Angeles Lakers win a championship. The Lakers, built around Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves and Walker Kessler, had entered the day 13-2 and on a nine-game winning streak.

“I’m looking at the brothers and I’m saying, LA doing special things. The Lakers are doing special things,” Smith said, praising coach JJ Redick, general manager Rob Pelinka, Doncic, Reaves and Kessler. He then added, “I ain’t never seen what they assembled, what they’re being led by, deliver an NBA championship in my lifetime. And I don’t think I’m going to see it this year.”

Later in the segment, he said, “I’m looking at the fellas. Y’all, LA look pretty damn good. These white brothers can play, they can play. They can win a championship. This is the NBA! Y’all gonna let them win a championship?” After a co-host suggested the comments might also motivate the Lakers, Smith said he did not “give a damn what color you are” and wanted “great basketball,” then repeated that “throughout NBA history, it hasn’t happened” and asked, “What y’all going to do about it?”

Williams, a former NBA point guard and an ESPN analyst, quoted a clip of the segment Wednesday afternoon. “This sounds like something you’d hear in the 1930s or 1940s, just with the racial dynamics reversed. Think about how disturbing that is,” he wrote. “We spent generations fighting to ensure athletes were judged by their talent, not the color of their skin. Now we’re openly questioning whether Black players should allow white players to win? At what point does fighting against discrimination turn into perpetuating the same mentality we fought so hard to overcome?”

Smith answered Wednesday evening by quoting that post. “You can bring up that b.s. all you want about the 1930’s, but I’m talking about right now,” he wrote. “I love this challenge to the fellas. I want to see if this generation of players are gonna succumbed to these Lakers. I said what I said and I meant what I meant. But I don’t hear you denying that what I said is true. I’m done with this convo. You know where the hell to find me.”

Smith has made a version of the argument since the summer, when he questioned whether a team led by “three white dudes” could win a title. He repeated earlier this month that he had never seen a championship team with a white top three and did not think the Lakers would be the first. The roster’s makeup has been a running topic around the team as well, including in September, when Redick said two open starting spots “will not be two white guys.”

The Lakers later lost 109-97 to the Utah Jazz on Wednesday night, ending the nine-game streak and falling to 13-3. They still sit among the top teams in the Western Conference. Smith had not posted a further public reply to Williams’ Thursday message.

Baltimore Ravens cornerback Marlon Humphrey looks on before a game at M&T Bank Stadium.
Previous Story

The Ravens Send Home Marlon Humphrey After His Comments About Baltimore

Next Story

Watch Cheerleaders Steal Show From UCLA Bruins Football Team Despite Its 10-0 Record

Go toTop