A Florida judge has ruled that former Miami Dolphins wide receiver Tyreek Hill does not have to undergo a court-ordered psychological examination in a civil lawsuit filed by social media influencer Sophie Hall, who alleges he violently charged into her during backyard football drills and fractured her leg.
Broward County Circuit Judge David Haines denied the motion in a ruling made public this week, court records show. Hall’s legal team had sought the exam in December to assess what they described as Hill’s “longstanding pattern of anger and aggression towards others, particularly women,” along with issues related to anger management, impulse control and aggression.
Hill’s attorneys called the request a “completely baseless intrusion” into his mental state and argued Hall failed to show good cause for it.
The latest development comes as the case, filed more than two years ago, heads toward trial, which had been scheduled for March.
Hall, a 36-year-old model and social media influencer known on Instagram as @sophiesselfies224, sued Hill on Feb. 23, 2024. She claims the incident occurred June 28, 2023, at Hill’s mansion in Southwest Ranches, a suburb west of Fort Lauderdale.
According to the lawsuit, Hill invited Hall — then a guest at his home — to participate in one-on-one football drills in his backyard. During a drill in which she played defensive line against him, Hall said she shoved Hill backward, causing onlookers to laugh. Embarrassed, Hill allegedly switched roles and “charged into her violently and with great force,” fracturing her right leg, the suit states.
Hall underwent surgery to repair the fracture, which required metal hardware implantation, her attorneys said. She is seeking damages in excess of $50,000 on claims of battery, assault, negligence and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Hill has denied the allegations. His attorney previously told ESPN the claims are “baseless” and that Hall actually injured her leg after tripping over a dog during the drills.
Court records also show Hall acknowledged in a 2024 deposition that she and Hill had sex hours after the incident and again the following day.
Hill, an eight-time Pro Bowl selection and five-time All-Pro, was released by the Dolphins on Feb. 16 amid salary-cap considerations while rehabbing a major leg injury from the 2025 season. He became a free agent and has said he intends to return to the NFL.
The lawsuit references Hill’s past documented history of violent behavior, which Hall’s team argued is relevant to the case. Hill was not charged criminally in connection with the 2023 incident.
Neither side immediately responded to requests for comment Wednesday.
The case remains pending in Broward County circuit court.
Flip the pages for thirst trap photos of Sophie Hall.
